Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Sailor Jerry vs Captain Morgan

Charl Joost
Last Updated: February 25th, 2023

Want to know the difference between Sailor Jerry vs Captain Morgan? Sailor Jerry and Captain Morgan are both well-known brands of spiced rum. Spiced rum is any rum flavored with natural herbs and spices.

If you have never tasted these two brands, you may wonder which is better in flavor, taste, and price. If you want to know which brand will suit your tastes and be value for money, this article will help you decide.

Sailor Jerry or Captain Morgan?

Sailor Jerry is a spiced rum distilled in the United States Virgin Islands. It is 92 proof and features a Sailor Jerry hula girl on the label.

Although it is slightly harsh to drink neat, the flavor is bold with vanilla, cloves, and cinnamon notes; it comes to life when mixed.  

Hardy, Malone, and Steven Grasse established Sailor Jerry Ltd. to create merchandise based on the life of Sailor Jerry (the nickname of Norman Collins), a famous tattoo artist.

In the 1990s, they started making Sailor Jerry Rum.

sailor jerry - Sailor Jerry vs Captain Morgan

William Grant and Sons, the company that produces the Scotch Whisky Glenfiddich, purchased Sailor Jerry rum in 2008, and it has become one of the most popular spiced rums in the world. 

Captain Morgan Original Spiced Rum is amber-colored and has a rich, sweet flavor of caramel and vanilla with a hint of baking spices. It has many varieties, the Original Spiced Rum being the most popular. 

captain morgan

Owned by Diageo since 2001, Captain Morgan dates back to 1944, when the Ontario-based Seagram Company started selling the brand under the name “The Captain Morgan Rum Company.” Production takes place in the US Virgin Islands.

With its spicy flavor, Captain Morgan pairs well with drinks like cola and ginger beer and, in 2014, was the second most popular spirit in the United States.

What are they made of?

Sailor Jerry Rum uses rum blended with “secret spices.” Spices that are detected are vanilla, ginger, cloves, and cinnamon.

Captain Morgan uses sugar cane to produce molasses to create the rum with which selected baking spices such as cinnamon, cloves, cardamom, and vanilla are blended.

How are they made?

The recipe for Sailor Jerry Rum follows the method used by sailors to improve the flavor of their rum rations. Aging in oak casks was not possible, so they blended in spices.

Sailor Jerry uses a selection of the best high-proof rums distilled in the Caribbean and infuses it with their “secret spices.”

how are they made

Captain Morgan 

  • Juices are squeezed from sugar cane to create molasses.
  • Yeast and water are added to the molasses and allowed to ferment and produce alcohol. Choosing the correct yeast will ensure the right and desired taste profile of the rum.
  • The fermented liquid goes through a continuous column distillation process.
  • The distilled beverage then matures in an oak barrel for a minimum of one year, adding character and a golden color to the rum.
  • A selection of matured barrels is blended, with flavors and spices added to produce the desired Captain Morgan Rum.   

How are they similar?

Sailor Jerry and Captain Morgan offer spiced rum at similar prices and are better mixed with cola or ginger beer or blended into cocktails. They are two of the best-selling spiced rums worldwide.

Price, Size, Color, Alcohol% Comparison

Sailor Jerry only produces spiced rum with a 46 ABV% or 92 proof.

It has a clear golden color with no sediment and is made with a combination of spices from the Caribbean to produce that distinct flavor that is warming with a balance of sweetness and a bitter alcohol kick.

Sailor Jerry has modified its formula to provide a sweeter taste with a reduced alcohol strength of 35 ABV%  to appeal to a larger audience in the UK.  

Captain Morgan offers a comprehensive range of products and different flavors of rum.

  • Captain Morgan Original Spiced Gold

This spiced rum, best served mixed with cola or in a cocktail, has intense flavors of vanilla and caramel. It is a medium-bodied rum that is 70 proof or 35% ABV and is the second highest-selling spirit in the United States.

  • Captain Morgan Black Spiced Rum

Black Spiced Rum is aged for a minimum of two years, giving it a dark color with smooth, smoky flavors. Spices and caramel coloring provide a signature sweet spice taste.

  • Captain Morgan White Rum

Captain Morgan White Rum is distilled five times and aged for a short time. It has nearly no color and a slightly sweet yet creamy taste. White rum is the most common rum used to make a Mojito.

  • Captain Morgan Silver Spiced Rum

Silver Spiced Rum is a blend of white rum and spices with a sweet vanilla character and can be sipped straight or on the rocks or mixed with your favorite cocktail. 

  • Captain Morgan 100 Proof Rum

Captain Morgan 100 Proof Rum is 50% ABV and made from a blend of Caribbean rums and selected spices to enhance the intensity of this high-proof rum. 100 Proof Rum is stored in charred oak casks to give this rum its smooth, mellow taste.

  • Captain Morgan Private Stock

Captain Morgan Private Stock is Captain Morgan’s premium spiced rum. Using a blend of the best Captain Morgan reserves and married with more exotic spices, Captain Morgan Private Stock has a smooth, velvety texture and is full-bodied.

Private Stock

  • Captain Morgan Flavored Rum

The following are flavored rums produced and marketed by Captain Morgan used mainly in cocktails: Coconut, Cannon Blast, Jack o Blast, Pineapple, Grapefruit, Watermelon, and Apple Smash.


Sailor Jerry and Captain Morgan both have a Golden color with no sediment. 

Name Size ABV Average Price
Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum 750ml 46% $19
1000ml 46% $22
1750ml 46% $26
Captain Morgan Original Spiced Rum 750ml 35% $15
1000ml 35% $22
1750ml 35% $25
Captain Morgan Black Spiced Rum 750ml 47% $25
Captain Morgan White Rum 750ml 40% $17
Captain Morgan Silver Spiced Rum 750ml 35% $17
Captain Morgan 100 Proof Rum 750ml 50% $24
Captain Morgan Private Stock Rum 750ml 40% $25
Captain Morgan Apple Smash Rum 750ml 30% $22
Captain Morgan Coconut Rum 750ml 35% $17
Captain Morgan Grapefruit Rum 750ml 35% $17
Captain Morgan Watermelon Rum 750ml 25% $17
Captain Morgan Pineapple Rum 750ml 35% $17
Captain Morgan Jack o Blast Rum 750ml 30% $17

How to Drink Sailor Jerry and Captain Morgan

Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum is sweet with a strong vanilla flavor. Sailor Jerry has enough flavor to drink straight or on the rocks; however, its authentic flavors come to life with simple mixes such as cola (rum &coke) or ginger beer.

Cocktail Recipes using Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum

Chica-Cherry Jerry

  • Two parts Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum
  • Half part vanilla syrup
  • Cherry Cola
How to make
  • Combine Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum and vanilla syrup in a highball glass.
  •  Fill with ice and top with Cherry Cola. Garnish with a fresh cherry.

Cup O’ Jerry

  • Four parts coffee
  • One & half parts Sailor Jerry
  • Quarter part heavy cream
  • One pinch of brown sugar
  • Garnish with cinnamon and whipped cream

Captain Morgan Spiced Rum is smooth enough to sip straight, with a dash of water or on the rocks. It is well known as a mix with cola (rum & coke), ginger beer, tropical fruits (mango, pineapple, and papaya), and lemonade.

Cocktails using Captain Morgan Original Spiced Rum


  • One & half oz. Captain Morgan Spiced Rum
  • Half oz. lime juice
  • Two oz. soda water
  • Crushed ice
  • One teaspoon sugar
  • Ten Mint leaves
  • Mix Captain Morgan rum, soda water, lime juice, and sugar together in a cocktail shaker. 
  • Fill a tall glass with ice and mint leaves
  • Pour the mixture from the cocktail shaker into the glass and mix well.
  • Add a dash of tabasco. 


Colada Tini

  • Two oz. of Captain Morgan Original Spiced Rum
  • One & half oz. cream of coconut
  • Three-quarter oz. pineapple juice
  • Ice
  • Grated cinnamon for garnish
  • Chill a martini glass
  • In a cocktail shaker, add ice, rum cream of coconut, and pineapple juice
  • Shake to chill
  • Strain into a chilled martini glass and garnish with grated cinnamon


The following Spiced Rum brands are alternatives to Sailor Jerry.

Kraken Black Spiced Rum is a spiced rum with more than 40% ABV, and the price is similar to Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum. Both rums are best mixed or in cocktails. The main difference is the color.

Sailor Jerry is golden, and Kraken is black.

Pusser’s Spiced Rum, spiced with ginger and cinnamon, is an excellent alternative if you want to get away from Spiced rums with a strong vanilla taste. It has a rich, warming taste even though it has a relatively low 35% ABV.

Try these Spiced Rum Brands as an alternative to Captain Morgan

Bacardi Select has a 40% ABV whereas Captain Morgan has a 35% ABV. Both are more popular in mixed drinks but are smooth enough to enjoy straight.

Bayou Spiced Rum is more expensive than Captain Morgan but is a worthy alternative if you a looking to try another quality Spiced rum.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which came first?

Captain Morgan came first when “The Seagram Company” started selling the brand under the (The Captain Morgan Rum Company) name. Then, Sailor Jerry Ltd. expanded its company to create Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum in 1991.

Which is stronger?

Sailor Jerry has a higher alcohol content with 46% ABV. Captain Morgan Spiced Rum has an  ABV of 35%.

Which is more popular?

Captain Morgan Original Spiced Rum rates as the second highest-selling spirit in the United States. Sailor Jerry is rapidly increasing its sales and popularity. The choice is yours.

Try both and decide. Both are quality options.

About The Author

Charl Joost

Charl is a trainer, public speaker, and professional writer. While he has been coached to niche down, he has many passions. These include golf, gardening, technology, and a decent cup of coffee or two. Charl loves to learn about new products and tries everything he writes about.

Just so you know, if you click on a product on and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

Leave a Comment