Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

The Best 5 Cup Coffee Makers (2024 Guide)

Ryan Marshall
Last Updated: December 30th, 2023

5 cup coffee makers are the most popular options on the market when it comes to smaller-sized coffee machines that still feature a glass carafe.

While there are even smaller coffee makers on the market, options smaller than five-cup coffee makers are only often able to brew one cup of coffee at a time.

Many people believe that the 5 cup coffee maker strikes the perfect balance between design and efficiency, as it allows owners to enjoy their first cup of coffee while their second cup stays warm and ready for pouring in the heated carafe.

Choosing the Right 5 Cup Coffee Maker

choosing right 5 cup coffee maker

When it comes to five-cup drip coffee machines for your home, there are dozens of different options to choose from. We have hand-selected five of the most important factors when it comes to selecting a machine, as there are many different 5-cup coffee makers that are reliable and affordable.

Price and Value

One of the best aspects of shopping for five-cup drip coffee makers is the fact that nearly all of them are fairly affordable. While high-end espresso and specialty coffee machines can cost upwards of $1000, five-cup drip coffee machines are generally priced under $60.

While many people use price as their primary means of determining which coffee maker they should choose, it is important to also consider the amount of value that a given machine presents before buying.

Value refers to the amount of quality received in exchange for the price, and many people choose to spend a few more dollars on better machines that are made with more durable parts and feature better designs.

Size and Weight

Another great thing about owning a five-cup coffee machine is the fact that they usually feature sleek designs that are slim and light.

While some people pay little attention to the dimensions of different coffee machines, it is important to choose a model that fits nicely into your kitchen space.

Five-cup coffee machines are also great options for those who travel with their own machines, as they are lightweight and fit easily into luggage or in the back of a car. Many people believe that these options strike the perfect balance between size and function.

Design and Durability

Five-cup drip coffee machines come in a variety of different designs, and choosing the best options for your home comes down to a balance of personal preference and product quality. Some options feature automatic timers, while others are more simple and only use a single switch for operation.

Many people choose to spend a bit more for five-cup coffee machines that are made with durable parts and have a good reputation for quality. Some people prefer coffee reservoirs that are made of glass, while others prefer the look of more shiny metallic carafes.

Brand Reputation

When it comes to smaller coffee machines that are not of the single-serve variety, the five-cup coffee maker is by far the most popular option. As a result, some of the top home coffee machine manufacturers on the market have five-cup options available, and there are many different models to choose from.

Due to the fact that the majority of five-cup home coffee makers are relatively affordable, there is little reason to choose a smaller and less established brand.

Some of the most recognizable brands on the market like Mr. Coffee and Black and Decker have five-cup options, meaning that there are multiple high-quality options to choose from.

Shipping Cost and Method

While shipping may not be the first factor that comes to mind for many people shopping for a new coffee machine, it is an important consideration that needs to be made. Some online retailers charge a flat rate for shipping, while others offer free shipping options.

It is also a good idea to take a closer look at the method of shipping that any given retailer uses before purchasing. The best retailers allow customers to choose from many different shipping options to find the option that works best for them in terms of both delivery window and price.

Quick Overview: Our Top Picks for Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker

dstblcr-table__imageMr. Coffee, 5-Cup Mini Brew Switch Coffee Maker
  • Auto Pause
  • Easy to View Water Window
  • Lift & Clean Filter Basket
dstblcr-table__imageBLACK+DECKER 5-Cup Coffee Maker
  • Sneak a Cup Feature
  • Easy to Clean Filter
  • Compact Design
dstblcr-table__imageKRUPS Simply Brew Compact Filter Drip Coffee Maker
  • Cup Warmer
  • Compatible with No.2 paper coffee filter
  • Modern Design
dstblcr-table__imageAmazon Basics 5-Cup Coffee Maker
  • Stain Resistant Warming Plate
  • Overheating and Dry Boil Protection
  • Visible Water Window
dstblcr-table__imageHolstein Housewares - 5-Cup Compact Coffee Maker
  • Auto Pause
  • Glass Carafe
  • Anti-Drip Design

The Best 5 Cup Coffee Makers

1. Mr. Coffee Mini Brew

Mr. Coffee is one of the largest and most recognizable brands in the world when it comes to home-based drip coffee machines. Their machines have developed a very good reputation over the years for providing a good balance between affordability and durability.

Mr. Coffee is the brand of coffee machine that is found in the guest rooms and suites of some of the largest hotel brands in the world, and five-cup machines are popular options when it comes to placement in hotel rooms and extended stay rentals.

The Mr. Coffee Mini Brew is one of the first five-cup coffee makers that many people think about when it comes to this category of moderately sized coffee machines, and it has been one of the top sellers on the market for many years.

It uses simple features like switch operation for one of the most straightforward and easy-to-use five-cup coffee makers on the market. It is available in both white and black, making it possible for different people to choose options that work best in their kitchens.


  • One of the most iconic five-cup coffee makers on the market
  • Mr. Coffee is an established brand with a very good reputation for quality
  • Proven to be one of the most durable options in the coffee industry
  • Available in two different color finishes to match the style of different kitchens
  • Auto pause allows owners to pour a cup of coffee mid-brewing cycle
  • Compact design that fits well into smaller spaces and kitchens


  • There are other models that have more color options available
  • Some people enjoy sleeker designs with sharper edges and lines
  • No auto brew or timer feature, which is a deal breaker for some

2. Black and Decker 5 Cup Coffee Maker

Black and Decker is a well-known manufacturer of everything from coffee makers to drills and power tools, and their 5 Cup Coffeemaker model is highly regarded as one of the most durable and reliable options on the market.

One of the first things that jump out to many people when looking at this particular model is the fact that it is priced at $40. While this is a relatively low price in comparison to many other coffee and espresso makers, it is at the higher end of the spectrum for simple five-cup options.

This machine uses a simple “on/off” switch for operation, and many people love the design of the included glass carafe. It features a tapered profile that is larger on the bottom compared to the top which makes it a very stylish and sturdy option.

Another popular feature that the Black and Decker 5 Cup Coffeemaker showcases is the reusable filter that is simple to clean after each use. This negates the repeated costs associated with buying paper coffee filters, which can add up and save significant money over time.


  • Sleek and small option that weighs less than two pounds
  • Stylish glass carafe with a tapered profile and ergonomic handle
  • Highly regarded as one of the most durable and reliable options on the market
  • Black and Decker is a highly trusted producer with top-tier quality control
  • Available at many of the top retailers in the world
  • Simple design that is very easy to operate and keep clean


  • One of the more pricey five-cup options on the market today
  • Some people prefer the convenience of auto-brew timer features
  • Only available in black with no other colors or finishes to choose from

3. KRUPS Simply Brew Compact

Many people consider the sleek and “boxy” design of the KRUPS simply brew to be very visually appealing, and the design makes it fit well aesthetically into a number of different kitchens with different interior design themes.

It uses a simple switch for operation, making it very simple for just about anyone to use. It features a permanent reusable coffee filter that is simple to rinse out and reload each morning after use.

Another thoughtful feature that many customers enjoy about this design is the fact that it has a clear window on the side of the reservoir that allows people to easily keep an eye on how much water they have added to the machine before use.


  • Stylish design that fits well into just about any style of kitchen
  • Simple features and hardware makes this machine very durable
  • Very easy both to use and keep clean
  • Many people have been using this style of coffee maker for years
  • Comes with a coffee measuring spoon for a proper bean-to-water ratio
  • Pause and brew feature allows customers to pour a cup of coffee mid-brew cycle


  • One of the higher-priced 5-cup coffee makers at $40
  • Not available in any other finishes or colors
  • Some people do not like the look of the included carafe

4. Amazon Basics 5 Cup Coffee Maker

Many people are familiar with the Amazon Basics brand, and the Amazon company strives to provide customers with high-quality alternatives to the current name brands on the market at a significantly lower price point.

The Amazon Basics 5 Cup Coffee Maker is a great example of the Amazon Basics business model in action, as this coffee machine features many of the same parts and hardware as options that cost $15 to $20 more.

This model showcases many of the same features as higher priced models like the KRUPS and Black and Decker options, making it one of the best values on the market in terms of “bang for your buck” in a five-cup coffee machine.


  • Simple design that is very durable and easy to operate
  • Showcases many of the same features as more highly-priced models
  • Many people enjoy the aesthetics and design of this simple machine
  • Shiny metallic finish makes this machine very sleek with a modern look
  • Allows users to pour a cup of coffee mid-brewing cycle without interruption


  • Only available in one color and finish option
  • No timer or auto brew feature beyond the simple on the switch
  • There are other designs on the market with better-looking carafes

5. Holstein Housewares 5 Cup Compact

The Holstein Housewares 5 Cup Compact Coffee Maker is one of the most stylish options on the market, and many people who love to express themselves through the display of bright colors tend to gravitate to this particular model.

It is available in many different unique color options, including teal, yellow, red, and mint. The fact that the handle of the included coffee carafe matches the selected color of the machine’s body is a nice touch, making this one of the most stylish options in the coffee industry.

At just under $30, this moderately priced coffee maker offers much more than just good looks. It showcases many of the same features as models that are priced much higher, making it a favorite among many different types of coffee enthusiasts.


  • Available in many different unique and colorful finishes
  • Features an auto-pause feature that makes it easy to pour an early cup
  • Comes with a high-quality reusable filter that is easy to clean
  • High-quality machine that is very reasonably priced
  • Free shipping for Prime members through Amazon


  • Not one of the most well-known manufacturers on the market
  • Many people prefer the peace of mind associated with larger brands
  • Only available for purchase online in many places

Best 5 Cup Coffee Makers – Conclusion

Many people love the simplicity and convenience offered by five-cup coffee machines, as they strike a fantastic balance between price and function in a small and easy-to-use package.

While there are many different options on the market today to choose from, many people find that the Mr. Coffee Mini Brew offers the best combination of quality, durability, and brand reputation at a very reasonable price point.

Click here to take a closer look at the Mr. Coffee Mini Brew, and decide for yourself if it is a good option for your home!

About The Author

Ryan Marshall

Ryan is a full time freelance writer who can most often be found on the disc golf course or local coffee shop when not behind a keyboard. He is an avid traveler and lover of all things sports and outdoors. Ryan is also a certified level one sommelier, and is endlessly curious about the world of high end beverages. Writing about wine, coffee, and other specialty beverages has given him a chance to take a deeper dive into his research, and he loves helping people find the perfect drink for their palates and preferences!

Just so you know, if you click on a product on and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

Leave a Comment