10 Best Winery Hotels in Long Island, New York (2024 Guide)

With over 60 wineries dotting its coastline along the Long Island Sound, and numerous more vineyards sprawling their way across its inland farmlands, Long Island is home to one of the most celebrated wine countries in the world.

Featuring award-winning varietals and a diverse wine selection only a two-hour train ride from Midtown, Long Island is an accessible wine region that attracts over 9 million visitors each year. It combines soft white sand beaches with hundreds of acres of delectable vines and awards an experience that combines an exploration of flavors with relaxation along its tranquil shores.

As a popular tourist destination, Long Island is also home to several accommodation options that promise various experiences and amenities that cater to different types of travelers.

So, whether you are looking to brush elbows with the rich and famous in South Fork or are looking for a quiet pastoral abode in West Suffolk County, these are the ten best winery hotels in Long Island.

Winery Hotels in Long Island — Tips and Advice

• While some vineyards on Long Island include nightly accommodation among their services, these convenient stay options are limited and often booked up quickly. Luckily, several hotels in the region offer excursions and tours to the many vineyards and often feature nearby tasting rooms for sampling the island’s offerings.
• Most visitors to Long Island’s wine region typically stay in the North Fork region, which is home to the vast majority of the island’s vineyards and wineries. Fantastic for touring several vineyards, North Fork is the ideal region for those seeking a deep-dive look into the industry.
• Alternatively, visitors can stay in the South Fork region. Known as the playground for the ultra-wealthy, South Fork offers plenty of idyllic views and promises a vacation bathed in opulence. Popular attractions in Southfork include the Hamptons and Montauk Point.
• Occupying central and western Long Island, West Suffolk County may not be as prestigious as North or South Fork. Still, it is home to some of the region’s best beaches, world-class golf courses, extensive shopping centers, and esteemed vineyards. It is a fantastic destination for visitors seeking diverse experiences in Long Island while sampling the region’s local wine industry.

The 10 Best Winery Hotels in Long Island, New York

1. Sannino Bella Vita Vineyard
2. Rose Hill Vineyards & Inn
3. American Beech Hotel
4. The Maidstone
5. Hotel Indigo Long Island
6. The Inn at East Wind
7. Montauk Manor
8. Mill House Inn
9. Hyatt Regency Long Island
10. Bridgehampton Inn

1. Sannino Bella Vita Vineyard

One of the few Long Island Wineries that offer an accommodation option directly on their property, the Sannino Bella Vita Vineyard is located in North Fork and is surrounded by miles of breathtaking scenery and long-spanning vineyards in the heart of the island’s wine country.

The most significant draw to this family-owned vineyard is the opportunity to explore the breadth of the facility’s winemaking procedures. Led by the property’s knowledgeable staff, guests are guided through an exclusive tour of the facilities as they learn the unique processes of boutique winemaking before ending their tour with a heightened wine-tasting experience.

After touring the complex, guests staying at the inn won’t have to worry about their way home. Instead, they can retreat to the privacy of the vineyard’s onsite inn, where they embrace a romantic bed-and-breakfast experience in a selection of Tuscan-styled suites and villas.

Guests who stay at the inn receive exclusive compliments, including a full hot breakfast delivered to their room and a complimentary tasting and cheese platter for two served at the vineyard’s Tasting House.

Additionally, each room at the Sannino Bella Vita Vineyard Inn features the ultimate comfort amenities, including private entrances, in-suite dining areas, a luxury marble bath with rain-head showers, and a private patio or balcony with picturesque views of the surrounding vineyards.

2. Rose Hill Vineyards & Inn

Another Long Island winery hotel that operates alongside a full-fledged vineyard, the Rose Hill Vineyards & Inn is one of the best accommodation options for visitors to explore the history and processes of the region’s winemaking industry.

Operating out of a 125-year-old barn, the Rose Hill Winery engages in a winemaking process crafted around the philosophy that fantastic wine should combine science, art, and folk wisdom to reflect the region in which it is prepared.

The result is some of the most delicious varietals made on the island, which visitors can explore at the facility’s tasting room which operates daily. The tasting rooms feature a spacious patio for enjoying favorite flavors during the warm season and ample indoor space throughout the year.

While the tasting room invites day visitors to sample its offerings, staying at the onsite inn is the best way to experience the vineyard.

Surrounded by 22 acres of the property’s vines, the inn features four guest bedrooms, complimentary breakfast and wine tasting, and easy access to over 40 additional vineyards that dot the surrounding countryside.

3. American Beech Hotel

Nestled in the heart of downtown Greenport on the southern shores of Long Island’s North Fork, The American Beech Hotel is a boutique luxury accommodation option well-situated to provide guest access to all of the region’s fantastic attractions and world-renowned wineries.

Located in the historic Stirling Square, the hotel is only a short walk from the East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation, the Greenport Waterfront, and several of the region’s top restaurants and tasting rooms.

But, of course, visitors don’t even have to leave the facilities to sample some of North Fork’s most delectable flavors. The American Beech Hotel features an onsite restaurant and four onsite bars and lounges where guests can sample award-winning cuisines and local vintages.

The dog-friendly hotel features a wide selection of room options, with each accommodation featuring opulent designs and luxurious amenities. In each room, guests will find king-sized beds, private bathrooms, a sitting area with lounge chairs, a coffee table, and a fully-stocked mini bar.

Rates at the American Beech Hotel start at $189 per night.

4. The Maidstone

Situated in the East Hamptons of Long Island’s South Fork region, The Maidstone Hotel is one of the best winery hotels in Long Island for mingling with the region’s wealthiest residents while taking advantage of the numerous surrounding vineyards and wineries.

The eclectic hotel features 19 guest rooms, each uniquely designed to reflect different influential Scandinavians. Each room features Jonathan Baker aromatherapy products, Hastens beds, Tivoli Bluetooth speakers, and a fully stocked minibar.

The hotel also features an onsite bar and restaurant, which offer a quaint period setting for enjoying favorite dishes curated using locally sourced ingredients and over 200 different local and international wines.

Alternatively, The Maidstone offers complimentary Kronan bicycles for visitors, allowing them to venture into town, where they have a more extensive selection of restaurants, shopping centers, and tasting rooms.

Rates at The Maidstone start at $494 per night.

5. Hotel Indigo Long Island

Located in West Suffolk County at the edge of the North Fork region, the Hotel Indigo enjoys a central location that serves as a fantastic base for visitors to explore the various areas of the island.

Nestled in a popular tourism neighborhood near the Long Island State Pine Barrens Preserve, the hotel is only a short walk away from several popular attractions and services, including the Tanger Outlet Mall and Splish Splash Water Park. Meanwhile, West Hampton Beach is only a short 25-minute drive away.

Of course, the Hotel Indigo also boasts its onsite services and amenities, making it a superb one-stop accommodation and one of the best Long Island winery hotels. Located onsite is the Bistro 72 Restaurant which serves regional wines and cuisines, and a lounge that offers all-day drinks and snacks.

Also offered within the hotel is an extensive onsite fitness center, a business center, a free shuttle service, and a wide selection of hotel rooms starting at $159 per night. All rooms include a spacious bathroom with a spa-quality shower, a work desk with ergonomic chairs, and Aveda toiletries.

6. The Inn at East Wind

Another excellent accommodation located on the outskirts of North Fork in the Western Suffolk region, The Inn at East Wind, offers an affordable full-service resort and spa. It is only a short drive from popular attractions such as Wading River Beach, Wildwood State ark, and Robert Cushman Murphy County Park.

The Inn at East Wind features a wide array of onsite services and amenities, including various shopping centers, an extensive full-service spa with an outdoor pool, three dining restaurants serving various dishes and vintages, and one of the most prestigious wedding venues in the region.

Other amenities featured within the hotel include an onsite fitness center and meeting facility, while horseback riding, cycling, and hiking excursions can be arranged through the hotel’s 24-hour concierge service.

Rates at The Inn at East Wind start at $116 per night for a King or Queen Room. All rooms at the hotel feature a private bathroom with a shower and tub, a TV with a CD player, and complimentary high-speed internet throughout the hotel.

7. Montauk Manor

Located within the popular tourist community of Montauk near the tip of Long Island’s South Fork, the Montauk Manor offers the elevated charms and amenities of a luxury accommodation option while maintaining cost-effective rates for travelers visiting on a budget.

Starting at $136 per night, all rooms at the Montauk Manor are uniquely decorated to accentuate the rustic charms of the community and feature a full kitchen with a dishwasher and microwave and a private bathroom with complimentary toiletries.

Included in their nightly rate, guests receive access to a massive selection of onsite amenities and services, including a full-service spa and wellness center, multiple tennis courts, extensive meeting facilities, and an indoor and outdoor swimming pool.

For entertainment, visitors can venture into the nearby community, where they will find a selection of restaurants, shopping centers, and tasting rooms. Alternatively, the Montauk Manor’s concierge services will happily arrange excursions to nearby vineyards or a horseback riding or fishing trip.

Additionally, the hotel’s convenient situation makes it a fantastic accommodation for basing an exploration of Montauk Point. The hotel is within a short drive of popular attractions, including the Montauk Point Lighthouse, Amsterdam Beach State Park, Camp Hero State Park, and Lake Montauk.

8. Mill House Inn

The Mill House Inn is another South Fork Long Island Winery Hotel that promises luxurious accommodations and a convenient location for exploring the region’s vineyards and attractions.

Operating out of East Hampton, the Mill House Inn is a high-class hotel with elevated amenities that reflect the surrounding neighborhood’s opulence. Each room at the pet-friendly hotel features supreme accommodation comforts, including luxury bathrooms and spacious seating areas.

Additional comforts offered in select rooms include private balconies with pool views, hot tubs, and a fully equipped kitchen for absolute convenience. Other onsite services include an outdoor pool, a communal terrace, an onsite garden, and hiking and cycling opportunities.

Other attractions within accessible distance of the hotel include Wiborg Beach, the Montauk Point Lighthouse, East Hampton Beach, and the East Hampton Golf Course.

Rates at the Mill House Inn start at $250 per night.

9. Hyatt Regency Long Island

Located in Hauppauge in Central Suffolk County, the Hyatt Regency hotel is located in the very center of Long Island. It is the ideal accommodation option for visitors planning to venture into the island’s hidden corners.

The hotel features a fitness center, an indoor pool with a hot tub, an outdoor pool, an extensive business center, and a 24-hour pantry stocked with favorite snacks and drinks.

But of course, what makes the Hyatt Regency one of the best winery hotels in Long Island is its close proximity to nearby attractions, including the RGNY, Palmer, Macari, and Pindar Vineyards. Other nearby attractions include the Vanderbilt Museum, Brookhaven National Laboratories Science Museum, and the Roosevelt Field Mall.

The Hyatt Regency features 358 elegantly designed guestrooms, each boasting luxury and comfort amenities, including refrigerators, dining areas, and air conditioning controlled by an included iPad.

Rates start at $216 per night for the hotel’s King Room options.

10. Bridgehampton Inn

Nestled in the heart of the Hamptons, the Bridgehampton Inn is a luxury accommodation that boasts an onsite restaurant, bar, shared lounge, and garden while remaining close to the Long Island’s world-famous vineyards and attractions.

Popular attractions surrounding the hotel include the Montauk Point Lighthouse, the Children’s Museum of the East End, the Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge, and both Gibson Beach and Mecox Beach.

Additional services offered at the Bridgehampton Inn include a continental breakfast or an a la carte breakfast served every morning, a communal terrace and shared lounge, and 24-hour room service. In addition, the Bridgehampton Inn Restaurant, Loaves & Fishes Food Store, and Cookshop are nearby.

All rooms at the hotel include private bathrooms with a shower and bathrobes and a flat-screen TV. Additional comforts in select rooms include hypo-allergenic facilities and private patios with garden views.

Rates at the Bridgehampton Inn start at $260 per night for the hotel’s Deluxe Queen Room.

The Best Winery Hotels in Long Island – Conclusion

Located only a short train ride from New York City and featuring over 60 world-renowned and diverse wineries and vineyards, Long Island is one of the most celebrated wine countries on the globe. The island’s three distinct regions attract over 9 million tourists annually, with each area promising a unique experience that caters to different travelers.

As a popular tourist destination, Long Island features a massive catalog of superb accommodation options as colorful and varied as the island’s surrounding vineyards. From luxury resorts in the Wealthy South Fork region to quiet bed and breakfasts in West Suffolk County, these are the best winery hotels in Long Island for each type of traveler.

• Best Luxury Winery Hotel in Long Island: The Maidstone Hotel
• Best Boutique Winer Hotel in Long Island: American Beech Hotel
• Best Cheap Winery Hotel in Long Island: Montauk Manor
• Best Romantic Winery Hotel in Long Island: Sannino Bella Vita Vineyard